人民长江 ›› 2022, Vol. 53 ›› Issue (9): 80-86.doi: 10.16232/j.cnki.1001-4179.2022.09.013

• • 上一篇    下一篇

月径流预报建模方法对比分析——以嘉陵江北碚站为例

陈雪怡;陈元芳;王文鹏;邱鹏   

  • 发布日期:2022-10-20

Comparative study on modeling methods for monthly runoff forecasting:case of Beibei Station in Jialing River

CHEN Xueyi1, CHEN Yuanfang1, WANG Wenpeng1, QIU Peng2   

  • Published:2022-10-20

摘要: 为提高径流预报的精度,以嘉陵江流域北碚水文站为例,选取1979~2019年径流资料,对比分析月径流预报多种建模方法的预报性能。选择时间序列法作为单变量预报模型的方法,随机森林、BP神经网络和多元线性回归作为多变量预报模型的方法,并应用时变权重进行组合预报,对比单变量与多变量、单一与组合模型预报结果。结果表明:(1)多变量预报模型预报效果更优,与时间序列模型相比,其平均绝对百分比误差减少约20%;(2)随机森林与BP神经网络这两种机器学习方法在单一模型中具有更好的预测能力;(3)时变权重组合预报方法能有效结合单一模型的优点,进一步提高预报精度。研究成果可为中长期径流预报的建模策略制定提供参考。

关键词: 径流预报;时变权重;随机森林;BP神经网络;多元线性回归;北碚水文站;嘉陵江流域;

Abstract: In order to improve the accuracy of runoff forecasting, taking Beibei Station in Jialing River as an example, the runoff data from 1979 to 2019 were selected to compare and analyze the forecast performances of various modeling methods for monthly runoff forecasting. Time series method was selected as a typical method for univariate forecasting model, random forest, BP neural network and multiple linear regression were selected as the typical methods for multivariate forecasting model, and time-varying weight was applied for combined forecasting. By comparing the forecast results of univariate and multivariate, single and combined models, the forecast performances of the mentioned modeling methods was analyzed. The results showed that: (1) The multivariate forecast models showed better forecast performance and the average absolute percentage error was reduced by about 20% compared with the time series model. (2) Two machine learning methods, random forest and BP neural network, had better predictive ability in single models. (3) The time-varying weight combination forecast method could effectively combine the advantages of single models to improve the forecast accuracy. The research results can provide a reference for the formulation of modeling strategies for medium and long-term runoff forecasting.

Key words: runoff forecasting; time-varying weight; hydrologic series; random forest; BP neural network; multiple linear regression; Beibei Station; Jialing River